Pizza Extreme Menu
89 items in 9 sections · $1.15 – $46.00 · Pizza Restaurant in Madison, WI
Pizza Extreme’s menu lists 89 dishes and drinks, grouped into Starters, Wings and Chicken, Hand Tossed Pizza, Oven baked Sandwiches, Chicago Stuffed Pizza, and Beverages and more. Prices range from $1.15 to $46.00, and a typical item costs about $13.79. Popular choices include Spicy Cheese Bread, 6 Extreme Wings, Veggie Version Pizza, Deli Extreme, and Bacon DBL Stuffed.
Starters 14
- Spicy Cheese Bread$5.98
Two 8” French Bread slices smoothered with mozzarella, cheddar and spices.
- Half Lb Potato Wedges$4.89
1/2 Lb Seasoned Potato Wedges
- Garlic Spinach Chz Bread$6.84
Chopped spinich added to our Garlic Cheese Bread makes this a classic.
- Garlic Cheese Bread$6.84
Our garlic french bread with a thick layer of Wisconsin’s finest melted cheese.
- 4 Garlic Breadstix$4.89
4 Pieces of toasted breadstix smoothered with garlic and parmesan cheese. Your choice of pizza sauce or nacho cheese sauce for dipping
- 6 Garlic Breadstix$6.61
6 Pieces of toasted breadstix smoothered with garlic and parmesan cheese. Your choice of pizza sauce or nacho cheese sauce for dipping
- Half Lb Fries$4.89
1/2 lbs Seasoned Potato Fries
- Jalapeno Poppers$10.29
Eight breaded jumbo jalapeno peppers with a side of ranch and stuffed with cream cheese.
- 1 Lb Potato Wedges$7.48
1 Lb Seasoned Potato Wedges
- Mozzarella Stix$10.29
Eight stix of creamy mozzarella slowly fried and served with marinara sauce.
- 1 Lb Fries$7.48
1 Lb Seasoned Potato Fries
- Cheesy Garlic Stix$16.04
A hand-tossed dough baked with garlic butter, extra cheese and sprinkled with Parmesan and Oregano 12 " or 14''
- Roni Stix$17.19
Pepperonis are added to our delicious homemade Roni Stix12” or 14''
- Garlic Bread$5.46
Two 8” fresh cut French Bread slices toasted with fresh crushed garlic
Wings and Chicken 9
- 6 Extreme Wings$9.20
- 18 Extreme Wings$25.30
- 40 Extreme Wings$46.00
- 16 Breaded Dippers$28.75
- 24 Wings Special$40.24
24 Wings, Large Fries and 2 cans of soda
- 12 Extreme Wings$17.25
- 8 Breaded Dippers$16.10
- Southern Chicken Tenders$14.89
3/4 Lb Dipped and battered with a Southern Style Peppery Seasoning and choice of sauce for dipping.
- 24 Extreme Wings$32.20
Hand Tossed Pizza 19
- Veggie Version Pizza$14.95
A vegetarian delight loaded with garden fresh vegetables: mushrooms,onions, tomatoes, green peppers, and black olives.
- Buffalo Chicken$14.95
Our Buffalo Chicken is topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Buffalo Chicken, Onions, Tomatoes, Cheddar Cheese
- Holy Macaroni Pizza$14.95
Cheddar cheese sauce, noodles, and topped with extra cheddar cheese. A Wisconsin mac and cheese classic.
- Spinach And Pesto Pizza$14.95
A blend of spinach, three cheeses and our delicious home-made pesto, made with fresh basil, garlic, parmesan, olive oil and walnuts.
- 5 Cheese Pizza$14.95
Our special mozzarella-white cheddar blend is topped with feta, swiss and cheddar, and then sprinkled with oregano and parmesan.
- KC BBQ Master Pizza$14.95
Your choice of chicken or seasoned ground beef, plus bacon, onions, peppers, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, and covered with sweet and tangy KC BBQ sauce.
- 5 Meat Pizza$14.95
WOW! Generous portions of our meat toppings. Italian sausage, gourmet pepperoni, ham, ground beef & bacon.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch$14.95
Just like it sounds: ranch, mozzarella, smoked bacon and chicken breast.
- Bucky Melt Pizza$14.95
A taste treat that will melt your heart! A double portion of Italian sausage and mushrooms, topped with cheddar cheese.
- Olympic Garden Pizza$14.95
Start with spinach, add sliced tomatoes, ripe olives, peppers & onions, and finish big with feta cheese.
- Take And Bake Thin Pizza$12.65
Our Take and Bake Thin Pizza is available in sizes 12'', 14'' & 16''
- Bacon DBL Cheese Burger$14.95
The finest lean double ground beef, a generous amount of bacon and fresh onions topped with cheddar cheese.
- Fire Alarm Pizza$14.95
For those brave souls! A mouth-burning experience! Gourmet Pepperoni, Italian sausage, jalapeño peppers and fresh onions, topped with extra pepperjack cheese.
- The Extreme$14.95
Lots of Italian sausage, gourmet pepperoni, mushrooms, fresh onions and green peppers.
- Hawaii 5 OH Pizza$14.95
Ham, pineapple, onions, green peppers and extra cheddar cheese.
- BYO Hand Tossed$10.35
Build Your Own Hand Tossed Pizza
- Taco Pizza$14.95
Your choice of chicken, seasoned ground beef is topped with salsa, onions, tomato slices, cheddar cheese and tortilla chips.
- Gyro Pizza$14.95
Choose from Chicken or Beef & Lamb Tender slices of chicken or select, hand-carved lamb and beef, broiled on a vertical skewer with imported Mediterranean spices, smothered with onions, tomatoes, special feta and cheese blend, and our speci
- Fresh From The Farm Pizza$14.95
Fresh spinach, fresh mushrooms, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella and feta cheese.
Oven baked Sandwiches 7
- Deli Extreme$13.79
Ham, Salami, Pepperoni & your choice of Sweet Green or Mild Banana Peppers add choice of Melted Mozzarella or Pepper Jack Cheese
- Capital Club Melt$13.79
Tender Slices of Turkey, with Bacon & Melted Mozzarella Cheese on Home Baked Bread
- Might Meatball$13.79
Tasty spheres swimming in tangy Marinara Sauce & Buried under melted Mozzarella Cheese
- Veggie Boat$13.79
A french loaf stuffed with Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Green peppers, Ripe olives and Marinara sauce with a blend of Chopped Spinach & Cheeses
- Chicken Parmesan$13.79
Crispy Breaded Chicken Strips topped with Marinara Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese served a Toasted Bun.
- Roman Emperor$13.79
Sliced, seasoned & juicy Roast Beef with a Marinara Sauce Flavored with Onions & Green Peppers, covered with Mozzarella Cheese
- Chicago Italian Beef$13.79
Shaved seasoned Beef with Au Jus, Mild Giardiniera & Melted Mozerella Cheese
Chicago Stuffed Pizza 13
- Bacon DBL Stuffed$20.70
Our Bacon DBL Cheese Burger is stuffed with Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Ground Beef, Onions.
- 5 Cheese Stuffed$20.70
Our Five Cheese Pizza is stuffed with Cheddar Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Feta Cheese, Parmesan Cheese & Mozzarella Cheese
- Fresh From Farm Stuffed$20.70
Our Fresh From The Farm is stuffed with Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Mushrooms, Spinach, Feta Cheese.
- Hawaiian Stuffed$20.70
Our Hawaiian 5-OH Pizza is stuffed with Cheddar Cheese, Green Peppers, Ham, Onions, Pineapple.
- Chicago HalfBaked Stuffed$14.95
Our Chicago stuffed pizza baked 1/2 way to finish baking at home
- Fire Alarm Stuffed$20.70
Our The Extreme Pizza is stuffed with Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Italian Sausage, Onions Gourmet, Pepperoni.
- Olympic Garden Stuffed$20.70
Our Olympic Garden Pizza is stuffed with Black Olives, Green Peppers, Onions, Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta Cheese.
- Veggie Version Stuffed$20.70
Our Veggie Version Pizza is stuffed with Black Olives, Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions.
- Spinach And Pesto Stuffed$20.70
Our Spinach and Pesto Pizza is stuffed with Spinach and Pesto
- The Extreme Stuffed$20.70
Our The Extreme Pizza is stuffed with Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Italian Sausage, Onions, Gourmet Pepperoni.
- BYO Stuffed$14.95
Chicago Stuffed Our signature deep dish pizza starts with a flaky crust, cheese and loads of those great fillings stuffed inside with our own homemade sauce on top!!
- 5 Meat Stuffed$20.70
Our 5 Meat Pizza is stuffed with Bacon, Ham, Italian Sausage, Mozzarella Cheese, Gourmet Pepperoni.
- Bucky Melt Stuffed$20.70
Our Bucky Melt Pizza is stuffed with Cheddar Cheese, Fresh Mushrooms, Italian Sausage.
Beverages 12
- 2 Lt 7 Up$4.60
- RC Cola Can$2.30
- 2 Lt Diet Dr Pepper$4.60
- 2 Lt AW Root Beer$4.60
- Dr Pepper Can$2.30
- Coke$2.30
- Bottled Water$2.30
- 2 Lt Dr Pepper$4.60
- Diet Coke$2.30
- AW Root Beer$2.30
- 7 Up$2.30
- 2 Lt RC Cola$4.60
Athens Gyros 10
- 1 Lb Fries$7.48
1 Lb Seasoned Potato Fries
- Lamb And Beef Gyros$13.74
Tender slices of our select, hand-carved lamb and beef, broiled on a vertical skewer with imported Mediterranean spices and piled onto a warm pita bread, smothered with onions, tomatoes and our special homemade tzatziki sauce.
- Half Lb Potato Wedges$4.89
1/2 Lb Seasoned Potato Wedges
- Extra Pita$2.30
Extra Side Of Pita Bread
- 1 Lb Potato Wedges$7.48
1 Lb Seasoned Potato Wedges
- Gyros Plate$17.19
Larger portions, plus choice of fries or seasoned potato wedges. Choose from three varieties: Lamb and Beef, Chicken or Vegetarian
- Vegetarian Gyro$12.36
Tomatoes, onions, cucumber, feta and lettuce piled onto a warm pita bread and smothered with our special homemade tzatziki sauce.
- Extra Tzatziki$1.15
Extra side Of Tzatziki Sauce
- Half Lb Fries$4.89
1/2 lbs Seasoned Potato Fries
- Chicken Gyro Souvlaki$13.74
Grilled chicken piled onto a warm pita and smothered with onions, tomatoes and our special homemade tzatziki sauce.
Desserts 2
- Chocolate Chip Cookie$2.88
Giant 1/4 LB Chocolate Chip Cookie
- 1 Pint Shoppe Ice Cream$8.05
1 Pint of Our Shoppe Ice Cream, Pick Your flavor.
Salads 3
- House Salad$7.19
Red onions, tomatoes, green peppers, cheddar cheese and croutons on a bed of our crispy lettuce blend.
- Greek Salad$14.89
Our crispy lettuce blend, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, feta cheese, olives, pepperoncinis and our homemade salad dressing.
- Chef Salad$14.89
Slices of ham, turkey, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses along with a hard boiled egg and red onions on a bed of our crispy lettuce blend.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated June 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.